In this lesson students learn about the design elements of a map and assess the value and limitations of using maps as sources.
How did different groups in the West experience U.S. expansion?
Second edition. January 2021.
At the dawn of the nineteenth century, North America was home to diverse Native American, European, and African groups. These groups and individuals experienced U.S. territorial expansion in very different ways. Groups betrayed and fought each other, but they also worked to understand each other across a chasm of cultural difference. In later years, people in the United States would tell a history of this period that left out the violence and racism, as well as the mutual adaptation, that accompanied this conquest. In many senses the very term “westward expansion” conveys an overly benign and incomplete sense of what actually transpired. This curriculum unit introduces students to the term “settler colonialism” in addition to the idea of “westward expansion” to emphasize the processes of Native removal and the acquisition of land by U.S. settlers. In recent years, scholars have worked to reexamine the history of the West by focusing on Native American groups. With limited sources, they have pieced together histories that do not generalize the experiences of Native Americans, and that accurately portray the complicated interactions that occurred in the West. The unit is divided into three parts. Each part includes:
- Student readings
- Accompanying study guides, graphic organizers, and key terms
Lessons aligned with the readings that develop analytical skills and can be completed in one or more periods
- Videos that feature leading experts
This unit also includes a Perspectives Lesson as the key lesson and additional synthesis lessons that allow students to synthesize new knowledge for assessment. You do not need to use the entire unit; feel free to select what suits your classroom needs.
Preview this unit. Preview includes the Table of Contents for the Student Text and the Teacher Resource Book as well as a student reading excerpt and one lesson plan.
Part I: The Transformation of a Continent
In Part I, students explore U.S. settler colonialism from a broad perspective by considering the major events and policies that accompanied U.S. westward expansion in the nineteenth century. There are two lessons aligned with Part I: 1) Legend as an Historical Source, and 2) Cherokee Nation v. Georgia, 1831.
Part II: Experiencing U.S. Settler Colonialism: Southern Arizona
In Part II, students explore this history on a local level using the groundbreaking research of historian Karl Jacoby on the effects of U.S. expansion on groups in southern Arizona. This case study is not emblematic of the entire West; rather, it allows students to understand the complicated and violent ways in which U.S. expansion affected specific individuals and communities. There are two lessons aligned with Part II: 1) Geography from Four Perspectives, and 2) Primary Sources from Arizona.
Part III: Telling New Stories
Part III describes the aftermath of the attack at Camp Grant. It examines U.S. policies, such as assimilation efforts and continued land confiscation, and asks students to consider how the absence of Native American views influences the way we remember the history of U.S. westward expansion. There is one lesson aligned with Part III: Rewriting History.
Legend as an Historical Source
In this lesson students examine a Kiowa legend about smallpox and consider its value as an historical source.
Cherokee Nation v. Georgia, 1831
After examining U.S. Supreme Court Justice Marshall's decision on the status of Indians in the United States, students analyze the government's role in determining the status of Native American groups.
Geography from Four Perspectives
Students practice map-reading skills and connect geography to historical events. Students use maps to explore claims that different groups made on lands in southern Arizona.
Indian Primary Sources from Arizona
Students use O'odham calendar sticks as primary sources to consider the connection between local history and the wider history of North America.
Considering the Perspectives
Perspectives Lesson: This is the key lesson in this unit. Working cooperatively, students research and present multiple perspectives about issues at play in southern Arizona in 1871, and consider the ways U.S. settler colonialism affected different Native groups, U.S. settlers, and Mexican Americans in the region.
In this activity, students analyze two accounts from 1871 of the attack at Camp Grant and consider the effects of missing voices in history.
Historical Memory—Aravaipa Canyon
Synthesis Lesson: Students design an exhibit for the Aravaipa Canyon Visitor's Center and reflect on the effects of U.S. westward expansion and the ways that people think about this history.
Assessment Using Documents — The Decline of the Buffalo
Synthesis Lesson: Students analyze primary and secondary sources in order to answer questions about the social, political, and economic factors that led to the decline of the buffalo population.